This week, our news and commentary take us from big questions about AI to flying cars and towering robots. We discuss a new chapter for Solo: A Star Wars Story, NASA’s “Dream with Us” student design challenge, Ukraine’s reported strikes on Russian bot operations, and Grok’s pitch to shop with your credit card. Plus, Tesla’s flying-car buzz gets a response from IKEA.
Then, James Sherwood, host of The Vault, joins us in segment two for a look at the card game World of Kylia.
Hosted by William Sikkens, Bill Snodgrass, and Gretchen Winkler
User Friendly is 100% human written, produced and hosted.
Enjoy the show? Like and subscribe on YouTube! Find our channel at [userfriendly.show](https://userfriendly.show).
Transcript
Welcome to
Speaker:User Friendly 2.0 with host Bill Sikkens,
Speaker:Technology Architect.
Speaker:And this is User Friendly 2.0.
Speaker:Welcome to this week's show.
Speaker:We're going to be having James Sherwood with The Vault in our next segment
Speaker:covering a card game that we saw at Rose City Comic-Con.
Speaker:It's going to be kind of a fun interview.
Speaker:He is back.
Speaker:He's been away a little bit
Speaker:dealing with, you know, life and all that kind of stuff.
Speaker:So it's going to be kind of fun to get this going again.
Speaker:World of Kalia is the game that we're going to be covering there,
Speaker:which I got a chance to look at to and was a lot of fun.
Speaker:So got that coming up. Bill.
Speaker:Gretchen, welcome to this week's show.
Speaker:What's new in your lives?
Speaker:Not much really.
Speaker:Yeah, I'm working on getting unveiled villains.
Speaker:Ready?
Speaker:Yeah. And, I know that's coming right up.
Speaker:And I'm going to give a little bit of a spoiler alert here.
Speaker:I got a chance to look at the poster you're putting together, and it's cool.
Speaker:It's creepy, but it's cool.
Speaker:But so is the second book.
Speaker:It definitely.
Speaker:Let's just say everybody that's been in our audience to test read
Speaker:has looked at this and gone, this is creepy.
Speaker:And no, that's not really what I was planning for.
Speaker:But, you know, hey, it's a good story and he holds your interest and stuff,
Speaker:and it's not like the whole thing is creepy,
Speaker:but there are some segments
Speaker:where you're describing the villains and boy, talk about,
Speaker:well, they're not villains if they aren't creepy.
Speaker:This is true.
Speaker:This is true.
Speaker:I don't disagree with you, but boy, yeah,
Speaker:we don't want bland villains that are like, yeah.
Speaker:Oh, he's so terrible.
Speaker:So, yeah, you know, and then fall asleep.
Speaker:Yeah. No, we don't want that. That would be.
Speaker:That would be bad.
Speaker:So, you know, it's interesting
Speaker:a couple of things that we've gotten some feedback on.
Speaker:And I'm just going to touch upon this.
Speaker:Well maybe do it a little bit more formally as number one
Speaker:we announced this last week, but the show is on YouTube
Speaker:now, a user friendly productions, our channel name.
Speaker:You can get to it through our website
Speaker:by going to our website and clicking the YouTube link.
Speaker:But what we're doing is
Speaker:this is something that's been asked for for a while, and I got some questions
Speaker:in from last week going, you know, what is what is it that you're doing?
Speaker:Well, we all have done this show
Speaker:since:Speaker:It started out on the radio.
Speaker:We still are of course on the air.
Speaker:And a lot of you are listening to us probably on on air.
Speaker:Obviously we do our podcast too and stream that, but the thing of it is,
Speaker:is that is not by nature designed to really have a video component,
Speaker:but it is:Speaker:The real reason
Speaker:I wanted to get us in a video version is so that you can have captions,
Speaker:and this is something that's been requested.
Speaker:We do have that with the audio version,
Speaker:but if you're listening on a device that doesn't have a screen,
Speaker:you know, like your radio, it would be awfully hard to view captions.
Speaker:In fact, it would be impossible if you could come up with way to do it.
Speaker:Let us know, because I'd love to feature it.
Speaker:But the one thing that YouTube has is we've put a visualizer together
Speaker:and some stuff.
Speaker:So it does have a video component, but it does have that feature.
Speaker:So if you want to listen but want to have captions like closed
Speaker:captioning is what I'm talking about, you will have that option.
Speaker:You do need to turn it on.
Speaker:They're not there by default, but it is an added feature for what you can do.
Speaker:And the other thing of it is, is comments.
Speaker:We welcome your comments.
Speaker:Now, one of the reasons why we've always had the comments come in
Speaker:through the website on the ask a question link is because, again,
Speaker:the original way that this show was done was on air exclusively.
Speaker:And you know, we've obviously adjusted with the technology,
Speaker:but we started from there and it doesn't give really a real time way
Speaker:to be able to submit comments, even listening to the podcast.
Speaker:There's different platforms we're on, all of them.
Speaker:Most of them, I'm going to say most. There's got to be one out there.
Speaker:Maybe we're not, but the point of it
Speaker:is, is even being able to post comments that way is somewhat difficult.
Speaker:You still have to go back to the website and all that kind of thing.
Speaker:So YouTube has its system built in for that,
Speaker:and that's another thing I'm hoping everybody will use.
Speaker:Please post your comments, subscribe.
Speaker:Like all the stuff that YouTube you know, have creators pray for every time.
Speaker:I'm not going to bug you with that so much.
Speaker:It does help get it out there, but the point of it is more.
Speaker:I'm hoping that this can be a way that you, as our listeners,
Speaker:can, in a real time fashion, be able to interact with the show.
Speaker:We welcome what you send in and that's how we do our programing.
Speaker:So, you know, that's one thing that's kind of cool to be able to offer that.
Speaker:Now, the second thing that I've been asked
Speaker:is to point out is that this show is produced by humanoids,
Speaker:I guess humans, right? Can I say humanoid?
Speaker:I mean, none of us are in Android bodies yet, but with the way
Speaker:sci fi is going, that might be, you know, year or two down the road.
Speaker:But the point of it is, is we do not produce with AI.
Speaker:So Gretchen does most of our research.
Speaker:The rest of us do some.
Speaker:All three of us are real people that are doing real commentaries.
Speaker:And this kind of thing is
Speaker:becoming a little bit less than norm.
Speaker:So, you know, if the question comes out there, do we use AI at all?
Speaker:Yeah, in some ways we do.
Speaker:I mean, we spell check to there are things like that.
Speaker:But what we don't do is have it right.
Speaker:Scripts, we don't have it, you know, right.
Speaker:The news or anything like that. We do our own research.
Speaker:Sometimes I'll go into AI and go, can you get me some verifications
Speaker:on these stories? And I'll go and verify that and that type of thing.
Speaker:So from that standpoint there's some things like that.
Speaker:But this is all human done.
Speaker:This is this has been something that we as a production team have done on our own.
Speaker:Bill, you edit without the use of AI.
Speaker:I mean, you do that yourself too, right?
Speaker:Yes. Yeah.
Speaker:So, shaking your head won't come through on an audio platform, so I.
Speaker:You know, I just want to throw this out there.
Speaker:We're going to get a header for the show for a while, promoting the,
Speaker:YouTube and all of that kind of stuff.
Speaker:But it's just a situation that we get asked this a lot, and I just wanted
Speaker:to put it out there and be very point blank on what we do and what we don't do.
Speaker:So what we don't do is use it for production.
Speaker:We don't use it for research.
Speaker:We in the sense of writing stories and that type of thing.
Speaker:I might use it kind of like as an advanced search engine to look things up.
Speaker:And sometimes we might use it for things like grammar checking
Speaker:and that kind of stuff, but that really is the extent of it.
Speaker:And everything else here,
Speaker:good, bad or otherwise, comes from us as a production team.
Speaker:And that is something that I think is
Speaker:a point of pride now, because these days that isn't always the case anymore.
Speaker:And it is we, you know, a big part of why we do this
Speaker:is because we love doing it and shoving that off
Speaker:to somebody else, or something like an AI model just doesn't make sense.
Speaker:Plus, you don't always know that what's going on is, is completely accurate.
Speaker:You know, and I'm a proponent, I'm not against AI.
Speaker:I mean, I think it's amazing what it can do, but it has to be looked at as a tool,
Speaker:and you have to check what you're getting back from it.
Speaker:And if you're using it for something, that's fine.
Speaker:But where people get into trouble is where they go to the AI and say, hey, do this.
Speaker:And then there's no further interaction. I wouldn't even do that.
Speaker:I've got some great employees and my technology company
Speaker:that have worked with me for years.
Speaker:I still check their work and they still check mine.
Speaker:We would never do anything different.
Speaker:And to have a computer program where you're going to hand that off to
Speaker:and not, you know, not have that degree of supervision just doesn't make sense.
Speaker:And that's where a lot of these problems are coming from, you know,
Speaker:so I've been asked by AI not to tell anybody
Speaker:about the planned world takeover, so I won't.
Speaker:But outside of that, no.
Speaker:But in all seriousness, we're human produced and we're proud of it.
Speaker:And we'll continue to do that. So anyway.
Speaker:All right. What do we have in the news this week?
Speaker:Well, obviously a topic that's really spot on.
Speaker:Explosive document claims that AI is not what we think.
Speaker:So what is it that we think?
Speaker:Well there you are, right.
Speaker:So interesting story that came out.
Speaker:This was published by Futurism.
Speaker:This was written by Frank Landy Moore.
Speaker:And again I apologize if I mispronounced names,
Speaker:but I want to make sure credit gets out where credit is due.
Speaker:So the headline in this is really bigger than the finding.
Speaker:This is about understanding AI's internal workings.
Speaker:It does not purport evidence that AI is conscious
Speaker:or secretly something else, or whatever the case may be.
Speaker:So a little bit of clickbait there, but the center idea is encouraging.
Speaker:I think some patterns inside AI that look confusing,
Speaker:kind of like a jumble, have a clear explanation.
Speaker:And researchers have gone into this, and they argue
Speaker:that better investigative tools reveal more understandable structure.
Speaker:So what's going on here is their deep diving into what is actually happening.
Speaker:When an AI does what an AI does, right.
Speaker:And the understanding of this will give researchers better ways
Speaker:to investigate failures, test potential fixes, bug fixing, all that kind of stuff.
Speaker:And while it's not a safety guarantee, it is definitely something
Speaker:that starts to kind of look behind the curtain a little bit.
Speaker:So there's a full essay connected to this.
Speaker:The researcher was Nick Cammarata.
Speaker:Again, I apologize if I pronounce the name, but look it up.
Speaker:The original essays out there, if you're interested in this futurism,
Speaker:again, covered the article and it's a good place to start with that.
Speaker:All right.
Speaker:Disney announces sequel to solo A Star Wars Story.
Speaker:Yeah, this is going to be kind of cool I think.
Speaker:Now the interesting thing is the original solo, A Star Wars
Speaker:Story was actually considered to be a flop.
Speaker:I know, which
Speaker:that's a Disney was going around saying,
Speaker:yeah, that was something that Jeremy complained about.
Speaker:Yeah, the numbers said it too. Unfortunately.
Speaker:I mean, as far as that goes now, as far as it being a good movie, I've watched it.
Speaker:My opinion, I enjoyed it.
Speaker:I don't know, Gretchen, did you guys see it when it came out or or ever?
Speaker:Yes, it was great.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Yeah, it was fun.
Speaker:And Peter Mayhew was really happy.
Speaker:He didn't have to roll around in the mud.
Speaker:Yeah, yeah, it was nice.
Speaker:See the movie for details. But anyway. Yeah.
Speaker:Pyramid, who of course
Speaker:played Chewbacca and he's in a fur suit and ended up in a mud puddle.
Speaker:But he had passed the baton.
Speaker:And after looking at that, Peter probably was very happy about that
Speaker:for not having to do that scene. But anyway.
Speaker:Yeah, but but yeah, so it's interesting to see what's going on here.
Speaker:However, there are some changes at Disney.
Speaker:If you haven't heard, Dave Filoni is at the head of the company now,
Speaker:and we're already seeing directions that seem to be going back to
Speaker:originally, how George Lucas kind of had envisioned things, which is kind of cool.
Speaker:So doing a sequel for this, I actually can see them,
Speaker:you know, picking up and going, hey, even though it might not have done
Speaker:so well at the box office, let's figure that out.
Speaker:Let's do a sequel, let's make it better.
Speaker:And that's what they're doing.
Speaker:So we'll cover this when it comes out.
Speaker:I don't have a release date on it yet, but I think it's something that done well.
Speaker:Could be a lot of fun.
Speaker:All right, the Dream with Us design challenge
Speaker:asks students to dream of innovations for the future.
Speaker:Can you explain what this is?
Speaker:So this is for students in grades six through 12.
Speaker:And the idea to dream of creative innovations for the future of aviation.
Speaker:This is being sponsored by NASA.
Speaker:The site is nasa.gov.
Speaker:Let me try that again. Nasa.gov.
Speaker:Dream with us and you can pull it up.
Speaker:Went live on the 23rd so it's open right now.
Speaker:There's an information session coming up on October 27th.
Speaker:It's virtual that you can sign up for registration deadline being December 8th.
Speaker:And they're also looking for judges.
Speaker:So if you're interested in judging, go there and you can sign up.
Speaker:That might be kind of something kind of fun for us to do.
Speaker:I'll look into that and see, see what the case may be.
Speaker:But anyway, so yeah, this is something that's kind of cool for the kids
Speaker:and something that you can actually directly interact with with NASA.
Speaker:Check it out again nasa.gov. Dream with us.
Speaker:President Zelensky says Ukraine bombed
Speaker:Russia data centers to take out social media bots dividing the West.
Speaker:All right. So interesting story.
Speaker:Been covered by a lot of outlets.
Speaker:We're going to go with the one from The Independent.
Speaker:Just because I had to choose one to deal with from this.
Speaker:But in the war with Ukraine and the monsters aka Russia,
Speaker:Ukraine is kind of this year, you know, David Goliath story
Speaker:really starting to get the upper hand and is making some progress, fortunately.
Speaker:So what happened is, is data centers in both countries
Speaker:had kind of been something that was not included in targets.
Speaker:Back in I think it was early September or late
Speaker:August, Russia decided to start bombing Ukrainian data centers.
Speaker:Now, when this happened, Ukraine had a set up
Speaker:because this was anticipated or years ago that this was going to happen,
Speaker:that a lot of their information
Speaker:is backed up in Western countries and that type of thing.
Speaker:And while it did create some problems with internet outages
Speaker:and that type of thing, they really, you know, were able to get back online.
Speaker:So when that became a line for battle on the front line, Ukraine
Speaker:responded by bombing three of Russia's data centers for a company called Yandex.
Speaker:The index is considered to be like Russia's Google,
Speaker:although it's
Speaker:kind of a combination of Google and some aspects of Amazon and some other things.
Speaker:They run a lot of apps for taxi services and financial accounts and on and on.
Speaker:So in doing this, all of that went down and created a certain amount of chaos
Speaker:for people that use these systems.
Speaker:It's going to take a long time to fix.
Speaker:Two of the three data centers contained Russian supercomputers
Speaker:that were being used to train AI models, so that's been knocked out.
Speaker:The index to this day is not disclosed.
Speaker:Whether or not these computers were damaged
Speaker:or if they're going to be able to recover them,
Speaker:but they're certainly offline at the moment.
Speaker:Well, what's happened with this?
Speaker:And we've had a lot of questions coming in about this too,
Speaker:is that it seems like a lot
Speaker:of the high intense comments, negative comments, things that would
Speaker:ramp people up that have been on social media have minimized.
Speaker:And while there's research being done on this,
Speaker:and there isn't direct evidence yet to be able to say that a led to be,
Speaker:it certainly would be a lot of questions if it didn't.
Speaker:And so President Zelensky of Ukraine
Speaker:has said that doing this is taking out a lot of the bots
Speaker:that have been causing problems and dividing the West.
Speaker:So one of the ways that Russia has been attacking
Speaker:kind of in a hybrid situation is by trying to create division
Speaker:within the West for supporters of Ukraine, trying to get people to not support
Speaker:Ukraine, you know, and that kind of a thing.
Speaker:And doing this through social media is actually a smart way of doing that.
Speaker:I have to give it to him that that is a way that would work.
Speaker:Now, one of the differences,
Speaker:because Russia has what they call a sovereign internet system, they don't.
Speaker:It's modeled after like North Korea and China, where they don't have a lot of
Speaker:outside influence.
Speaker:It also means that they don't have a lot of redundancy.
Speaker:So taking these things out is taking this stuff offline.
Speaker:The debate that's brewing right now in engineering circles is
Speaker:is it, as Zelensky says, that it's taking out the bots, or is it because
Speaker:it's taking out their ability to search and then use the bots,
Speaker:or a combination thereof, because he is the searching engine too.
Speaker:So it'll be interesting to see where this goes to.
Speaker:First of all, see
Speaker:if there's evidence that this is the case beyond circumstantial evidence.
Speaker:That is, data center stopped working, bots stopped happening.
Speaker:But, you know, maybe it was the phase of the moon.
Speaker:You never know until you can prove it,
Speaker:even though it's very convincing that those two are connected.
Speaker:It's not a fact yet.
Speaker:But at the end of the day, you know, from what President Zelensky
Speaker:is talking about here, this is something that
Speaker:will be of a benefit because we don't need any more division.
Speaker:We just don't.
Speaker:So not having this be the case would be kind of interesting.
Speaker:It will follow this.
Speaker:And as soon as there's some traction and some different definition on what
Speaker:actually happened here that we can document, we'll talk about it.
Speaker:All right.
Speaker:Well, Elon Musk says uploading a credit card photo.
Speaker:Let's rock shop for you.
Speaker:So, Gretchen, which of you have tried this
Speaker:or have both of you and how did it go?
Speaker:I didn't know I looked.
Speaker:Do I look stupid?
Speaker:Because, I mean, I may not
Speaker:be, you know, a fashion model, but not that stupid.
Speaker:So, you know whether Mr. Musk says this works or not.
Speaker:Can you imagine?
Speaker:Basically what's going on here is you're giving an AI
Speaker:your financial information and saying, hey, this is what I want, go shop for me.
Speaker:What could possibly go wrong?
Speaker:And, I stand a go
Speaker:tell, tell people not to do this. Yes.
Speaker:Yeah, I would advise against.
Speaker:But it's not just me even visas a advising against doing this.
Speaker:So this is an article on Yahoo Finance.
Speaker:Danny Santana wrote this talking about what's going on here.
Speaker:And basically it's kind of what the headline says.
Speaker:You can have grok do your shopping for me, Musk wrote.
Speaker:I ask grok to research the most fun Lego
Speaker:Star Wars kits for young kids and order them as easy as that.
Speaker:So you're giving the bot the the model here, grok your credit card
Speaker:information and just saying go out and order this for me.
Speaker:Well,
Speaker:yeah.
Speaker:You know, maybe that's easy for him to do because he's got so much money.
Speaker:It's possible matter. Yeah.
Speaker:And just a commerce, which is what this is called, is slowly gaining momentum.
Speaker:But I don't know.
Speaker:I still
Speaker:am concerned about asking my chat assistant that he has access
Speaker:to my accounts on Amazon to reorder something, much less something like this.
Speaker:So, you know, but let's put it out this way and not,
Speaker:you know, come up with a totally we wouldn't do a type thing.
Speaker:Have you done it? Go to our website. Let us know if it worked.
Speaker:Well I want to hear that too. And I will talk about it.
Speaker:If you went out and this did something for you and that's great.
Speaker:It's just not something I'm willing to try.
Speaker:So I'd love to get some feedback on that.
Speaker:All right.
Speaker:And more Elon Musk news.
Speaker:Did Tesla really just unveil a flying car.
Speaker:So this has been all over the place
Speaker:trying to figure out what's actually going on here.
Speaker:In my opinion, I would say the answer to this is no.
Speaker:It's the concept of one though.
Speaker:So what's going on here is a new version of Tesla's Roadster
Speaker:electric sports car now has thrusters and other things
Speaker:that apparently allow it to hover and turn mid-air.
Speaker:They've unveiled this in Texas.
Speaker:But when you start digging into this, it's
Speaker:looking like it has actually thrusters that are pushing it off of a track.
Speaker:There's some different things going on here.
Speaker:Did it hover?
Speaker:Maybe, it went up a steep ramp, spun in the air and landed using air jets.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Whether or not that actually is the case, and like I said,
Speaker:I've had some difficulty actually documenting this one way or the other.
Speaker:It's definitely not something that you're going to be seeing at your dealership
Speaker:anytime soon without a lot of changes being made to it.
Speaker:ing you can buy this thing in:Speaker:and all you have to do is go make a deposit of $500,000, and it's
Speaker:not guaranteed that you'll get the car that's in the terms and conditions.
Speaker:I think those terms and conditions.
Speaker:Oh, okay.
Speaker:I throw shade at Tesla's
Speaker:Tesla with safe and affordable flying car.
Speaker:So explain what that means.
Speaker:Well, I mean, you know, I leave a tie.
Speaker:Kia Tesla's flying car already has competition.
Speaker:And you said I kids for the people who brought you
Speaker:a bookshelf in an argument about how to assemble it.
Speaker:Yeah, yeah.
Speaker:So I can't Taiwan answer Tesla's big rival with a playful new
Speaker:ad featuring little Abo.
Speaker:And I never can pronounce these words correctly because they're Swedish.
Speaker:20 cars and a bathtub arranged to suggest the stunt ramp.
Speaker:It's pitch safe and affordable.
Speaker:The four piece settle set you back $12.99.
Speaker:Finally, a car collection I can afford, although I may have to finance the towel.
Speaker:This comes from Ikea.
Speaker:The technology.
Speaker:Tesla has thrusters and advanced engineering.
Speaker:IKEA's version runs on imagination, and somebody's making room noises.
Speaker:So anyway.
Speaker:So yeah, what they've done here is
Speaker:they've created a set of toy cars and using a towel as a ramp,
Speaker:they've made this work, which, after reading the press release
Speaker:on the flying car, in my opinion,
Speaker:might be just about as much of a flying car as what Tesla debuted.
Speaker:But yeah, we'll have to do the research on it.
Speaker:I'm not saying it's not.
Speaker:So you have the added benefit that you can also use
Speaker:the launch pad to dry off after you take a shower.
Speaker:So multiple use.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I Neo Drawer
Speaker:Dynamics debuts a 13ft tall humanoid robot.
Speaker:So yes.
Speaker:Being reported by Gadget Review here.
Speaker:This is something that
Speaker:if we talk about sci fi meeting real life,
Speaker:this was debuted in Beijing,
Speaker:and it's basically a four meter tall
Speaker:robot waiting at about 1.2 tons,
Speaker:and it can lift the lot.
Speaker:It's a hydraulic bet. It's this huge thing.
Speaker:41 degree active degrees of freedom, 39 joints.
Speaker:The claims being here that
Speaker:this can really do a lot.
Speaker:And I don't know, Bill, you might know about a little bit about this.
Speaker:There's been Asian cartoons that are giant robots fighting.
Speaker:I know Jeremy watched some of this, and I could see this being used
Speaker:for that purpose.
Speaker:Probably.
Speaker:I mean, granted, they'd have to bring the price down
Speaker:quite a bit so that it's more affordable for.
Speaker:Oh, you know, it's only money, right?
Speaker:How much does this thing cost?
Speaker:I didn't even see that in the press release.
Speaker:Maybe Elon will tell grok to buy it for him.
Speaker:Yeah, that's that's cool.
Speaker:So yeah, let's, let's see if that works out.
Speaker:Or maybe we'll just tell grok to buy it for him.
Speaker:Forget forget the, the credit card owner.
Speaker:But anyway, so the thing of it is, though, is I will have to say this.
Speaker:Looking at, technology like this, we're poking fun at it a little bit.
Speaker:But at the end of the day, there are uses for this.
Speaker:I mean, you know, there could be cool work at height and, you know,
Speaker:looks cool and, you know, walking down the street and then pressing everybody
Speaker:that be kind of a cool use for it, but I'm not sure it'd be worth the price.
Speaker:But hey, you know, and again,
Speaker:like I say as we're covering this, I've been trying to go through the article
Speaker:here, the press release, I don't see a, retail price on it.
Speaker:One probably hasn't been published yet.
Speaker:I can only imagine
Speaker:with the next generation of game consoles being over $1,000.
Speaker:I don't know how much would a 13ft tall, fully working, articulated robot go for?
Speaker:I mean, I probably a little more.
Speaker:You would 1.5 million. 1.5.
Speaker:Yeah, I could see it being at that price.
Speaker:So that kind of a thing. So anyway.
Speaker:All right.
Speaker:Well that's our news for this week.
Speaker:Next week we're going to be talking about subscriptions.
Speaker:Not that this is a new topic for us, but HP has come up with a,
Speaker:interesting take on this.
Speaker:I will just leave it at that.
Speaker:That people are not responding to positively to.
Speaker:We're also going to be updating you on what's
Speaker:actually going on with the PS5 and all of that kind of stuff.
Speaker:And again, at the end of the day,
Speaker:subscriptions are getting a little bit out of control.
Speaker:I will tell you that the governments are starting to get involved in this.
Speaker:A representative in New York is proposing a law to kind of ring in this
Speaker:in a little bit.
Speaker:So we're going to be talking about that too.
Speaker:Again, that'll be coming up next week here on User Friendly next segment.
Speaker:We are going to be talking
Speaker:card games and welcoming back James Sherwood from the vault.
Speaker:I'll be back after the break.
Speaker:This is user friendly 2.0.
Speaker:Check us out at User Friendly Dot show.
Speaker:This is your one stop for everything.
Speaker:User friendly can submit your questions.
Speaker:Submit your comments.
Speaker:Check out our different shows even look back now
Speaker:what going on 14 years which is a little bit amazing.
Speaker:So all right, over the course of this fall, we're going to be doing some
Speaker:features on a couple of different things.
Speaker:We are going to be featuring Bill, your
Speaker:Deming and talking about that a little bit more and some things like that.
Speaker:After that, we're going to be featuring your new book, Gretchen in October,
Speaker:or actually would be November for Unveiled Villains.
Speaker:And then we are going to be doing our Season of Giving,
Speaker:and we'll be announcing who that is when we get a little bit closer to it.
Speaker:So we got all of that coming up, which is going to be really kind of cool today.
Speaker:We're going to be doing something a little bit different in this segment,
Speaker:and we're going to be bringing James Sherwood with the vault back.
Speaker:He has been a little bit away and not even a little bit
Speaker:a lot away for a couple of months now working on some family stuff
Speaker:and just life happens, you know, these type of things.
Speaker:But he is back.
Speaker:He's going to be giving us a review on a game called World of Kalia.
Speaker:This is something that we saw
Speaker:at the Rose city Comic-Con, which was really kind of cool.
Speaker:And he's going to deep dive into that and talk a little bit about that.
Speaker:So, he has a really cool guest, by the way, on that.
Speaker:Me so we'll have that coming up here in just a second.
Speaker:But before we jump into that, I don't know, card games.
Speaker:Bill, do you think it seems like the tabletop card
Speaker:games have start have started researching in popularity lately?
Speaker:Have you noticed that or is it just me?
Speaker:Oh, there have been popular for a few years now, but with Magic The Gathering,
Speaker:Pokémon against humanity.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:You know, I and I know Park, you know, Pokemon and all that.
Speaker:It just seems like it rose city this year a lot, and last year a little bit.
Speaker:And some of the other things.
Speaker:There seems to be a lot of indie developers making these games now,
Speaker:which that I think is what I'm asking is, have you seen this
Speaker:as a kind of a new thing, or is it just I'm just noticing it?
Speaker:Oh, no, that's kind of a it's been noticing it more, but
Speaker:it is kind of a new boom that is occurring.
Speaker:I'm glad to see it.
Speaker:I think it's kind of cool.
Speaker:And, you know, we all support any developers anyway, but
Speaker:it's kind of fun to see this type of thing coming up.
Speaker:So cool.
Speaker:All right, let's go ahead and jump into the vault.
Speaker:Welcome to the vault.
Speaker:Well, we dig into anything related to games, gaming or having a good time.
Speaker:I'm your vault keeper, James Sherwood.
Speaker:Now it's time to break into some fun.
Speaker:Welcome back to the vault.
Speaker:This is James Sherwood.
Speaker:It's been a while.
Speaker:With me today is Bill skins.
Speaker:Welcome, Bill. Always a pleasure to be here.
Speaker:So today we're going to be touching on a game
Speaker:ked up at Rose city Comic-Con:Speaker:new game. It just came out in:Speaker:They're about to release their second season.
Speaker:It's an independent game developer called IQ pictures
Speaker:and the game is World of Kalia Ascendant.
Speaker:It is a first person, which I thought was interesting.
Speaker:Trading card game. Okay.
Speaker:It was created again in:Speaker:It is. It started as a
Speaker:a not as a game, but as a
Speaker:comic book, anime and story world
Speaker:that people wanted to be able
Speaker:to create characters for.
Speaker:And they started taking some characters
Speaker:and turn them into avatars for this game.
Speaker:I got to meet with Chase, who was the creator of the game at Rose city.
Speaker:Comic-Con had a lot of really good information on it,
Speaker:but it's kind of a neat, a neat take.
Speaker:They've having it be based on stories and comic books.
Speaker:There's a lot of law and a lot of interesting pieces
Speaker:that are picked out by that.
Speaker:Second season is on preorder now. So,
Speaker:you just search for World of Kalia and you can find it there.
Speaker:It is a first person trading card game.
Speaker:So does first person mean?
Speaker:Well, rather than controlling
Speaker:an army, you control a person.
Speaker:Okay, so I am Bob,
Speaker:and rather than playing
Speaker:zombies and skeletons and all these other things,
Speaker:I get new equipment, I get new skills,
Speaker:I get new racial traits, I get things like that
Speaker:so that I am the one actually doing the combat.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:You look at most of them,
Speaker:you look at Laura Karna, you look at Magic The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!
Speaker:It's you controlling resources.
Speaker:And this is instead, you are the resource making
Speaker:tactical choices for yourself.
Speaker:Okay?
Speaker:It has a very interesting mechanic
Speaker:and that it doesn't have resources.
Speaker:Okay, so Magic the gathering, you have your mana in Larkana,
Speaker:you have ink, Pokemon.
Speaker:You have energies in this one.
Speaker:As Chase told me several times,
Speaker:they wanted to come at it from almost a go fishing angle.
Speaker:So you draw a lot of cards.
Speaker:You have to have copies of the card in order to be able to play it,
Speaker:so it's anywhere from 1 to 4 copies needed.
Speaker:If it's a one copy card, when you have one,
Speaker:you can put it down on your deck or down on your playfield.
Speaker:If it's a three copy card, you have to wait until
Speaker:you have three of them and you play them all as the stack.
Speaker:So kind of a neat twist on it.
Speaker:And you have enough cards in the beginning, and you're drawing
Speaker:enough cards to really make it
Speaker:a feasible system.
Speaker:Okay. All right.
Speaker:So I'm just trying to think now,
Speaker:I'm hardly an expert on card games like this, but I've played some of them.
Speaker:I don't think I've ever heard of a first person
Speaker:neither before.
Speaker:And that's one of the things that made this.
Speaker:It kind of caught my eye and made it fun.
Speaker:I got to play a demo game while we were at the convention.
Speaker:It adds an element
Speaker:of investment into it, right?
Speaker:I mean, yeah, that makes sense now.
Speaker:I also heard that this isn't completely absent.
Speaker:You do get to roll dice, right? You do.
Speaker:So how it works is
Speaker:when it's your turn, you can attack.
Speaker:So you play cards, your cards give you different
Speaker:abilities and different bonuses, and then you decide to attack, and
Speaker:and you can either punch them in the face or you can throw a rock at them.
Speaker:And then, of course, as you gain abilities, you gain different weapons and things.
Speaker:So what you do is you roll a 20 sided die,
Speaker:the other person rolls a 20 sided die for a melee attack
Speaker:to see if you can close the distance with them.
Speaker:If you can close the distance,
Speaker:then you roll for the attack and then you roll for damage.
Speaker:Okay, if it's arranged, attack.
Speaker:It works a little bit differently.
Speaker:Its roll once to see if you hit them and then roll again
Speaker:for damage.
Speaker:But you get that randomness from having dice.
Speaker:And if you're like me, it means you get to collect more pretty d20.
Speaker:Well, I mean, there's always that.
Speaker:And that's the primary reason, of course, but it also seems like it's
Speaker:an interesting blend of two different things that would work well together.
Speaker:It is, and it was very surprising for me.
Speaker:It took me about five minutes to catch on the entire time.
Speaker:Playing an entire game with them.
Speaker:Teaching me took me:Speaker:It has a neat set of randomness.
Speaker:There is still resource management and that you have cards
Speaker:that you have to burn or or discard or things like that,
Speaker:but it makes it a much more streamlined, much easier gaming system.
Speaker:That's just a lot of fun.
Speaker:And being able to roll the dice adds
Speaker:that extra little bit of,
Speaker:that extra little bit of randomness for that extra little bit of chance.
Speaker:The way it's designed is your melee attacks are going to do a lot more damage.
Speaker:If it lands.
Speaker:Your ranged attacks do quite a bit less damage,
Speaker:but you don't get a reprisal attack
Speaker:like if you miss on a melee, so they do a good job.
Speaker:Anyone who's actually been in a fight take a martial arts gun
Speaker:picked on on the playground, or whatever the case may be.
Speaker:It's not just I do something, I stop, you do something.
Speaker:So this is you're playing off
Speaker:of each other's turns and you're you're playing all the way through,
Speaker:rather than sitting there twiddling your thumbs, waiting
Speaker:for the other person to finish playing cards.
Speaker:No, that's that's cool. So what do you need to get play on this?
Speaker:So what's your entry?
Speaker:So entry. If we're looking at
Speaker:the equipment
Speaker:you need, you need a deck of 80 cards.
Speaker:You need something to track life.
Speaker:You start with 70 life.
Speaker:And you will gain
Speaker:or lose life based on taking damage or healing and things like that.
Speaker:And then you need one to 1 to 3, 20 side to dice.
Speaker:Okay?
Speaker:That's all you need.
Speaker:That doesn't sound too intense.
Speaker:It's not.
Speaker:And price wise, a starter deck runs 25 to $30.
Speaker:That comes with 80 cards.
Speaker:I believe it comes with two dice.
Speaker:It's set up for a play style.
Speaker:You can play a tank, you can play a healer,
Speaker:you can play support, you can play this multi-player.
Speaker:So you could have 3 or 4 people at one table playing.
Speaker:And and it works just fine, right?
Speaker:Booster packs are 15 cards.
Speaker:They run around $6 a booster.
Speaker:When I say they run around right now, season one's on sale.
Speaker:Season two is preorder, so it's like $25 for a starter deck
Speaker:from season one, $30 for a starter deck from season two.
Speaker:Okay,
Speaker:so boosters are
Speaker:anywhere from 5 to $6 a piece depending,
Speaker:and it's 15 random cards.
Speaker:The other neat idea that they did
Speaker:is they created what's called Armory packs,
Speaker:and an Armory pack is 40 cards,
Speaker:that is, four copies, each of ten cards apiece.
Speaker:Okay. And it runs around $10.
Speaker:And one of the reasons they did that is you can go in on it with your friends
Speaker:so that you have the possibility for multiple people to get complete
Speaker:sets of a card, or is the most you need to play any particular card.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:So you can trade with your friends out of that one pack and say,
Speaker:hey, we've got this one card that's a two to play.
Speaker:Each of us get one.
Speaker:I really want this four card set.
Speaker:You can have these other ones.
Speaker:Really makes it
Speaker:an easy to get into into game.
Speaker:The other thing they do is they have, they allow proxies and things like that.
Speaker:For those of you who aren't up on all of the lingo,
Speaker:proxy is you can actually print copies of the card
Speaker:on cardstock at home, cut them out and play with them.
Speaker:Oh, really?
Speaker:Okay, that is a no no in some games I know.
Speaker:So, in a lot of games it is.
Speaker:But they want to keep it manageable.
Speaker:They want to keep it fun and they want to keep it going for the fans.
Speaker:Okay, okay.
Speaker:Now that makes total sense.
Speaker:So let's talk about the esthetics of it a little bit. What do you think.
Speaker:Did they take some time putting it together.
Speaker:Does it look nice or is it do you feel like you're in an industrial warehouse?
Speaker:Not quite an industrial warehouse.
Speaker:The artwork is actually very good.
Speaker:They have if you go to their website,
Speaker:they have a number of people listed as artistic developers,
Speaker:so it easily on par with something like a magic The Gathering.
Speaker:There are a couple of different artistic styles in it, but it does
Speaker:tend to track that fantasy,
Speaker:kind of anime style artwork in it.
Speaker:They spent quite a bit of time coming up with unique flavor text for it.
Speaker:Okay, so rather than it just being a card saying, oh, you get plus two to attack,
Speaker:it'll have little bits of of flavor,
Speaker:little bits of story and law on the.
Speaker:Okay, okay, cool.
Speaker:That's what we mean by flavor text.
Speaker:One of the other things, and I can't tell you how much I value this.
Speaker:As somebody who wears glasses and is getting older, it is very easy to read.
Speaker:The cards are laid out very smoothly.
Speaker:The, symbols are easy to interpret.
Speaker:It's just
Speaker:a pleasure to actually pick up the cards.
Speaker:The cards themselves are good quality.
Speaker:They're a nice cardboard or a nice.
Speaker:Not cardboard.
Speaker:The heavy weighted
Speaker:cardstock, that's the word I wanted, right?
Speaker:Good quality.
Speaker:Yeah, they're good quality. They feel good.
Speaker:They shuffle. Well, I'm not going to shuffle mine.
Speaker:They're going to go into card sleeves in order to play with it.
Speaker:Again, an entire game.
Speaker:One of the things that that I really like about it.
Speaker:For anyone who's played Modern Gathering,
Speaker:I've seen games take 2 to 3 hours to go through this one.
Speaker:A long game is 20 to 30 minutes. Okay.
Speaker:So that's actually that's kind of cool to you.
Speaker:You know, you sit down and you don't you don't have to go quite as long.
Speaker:So that sounds cool all the way around. And you know, it's interesting.
Speaker:I can tell as I get a little older myself, even though I've decided to stop aging
Speaker:this year.
Speaker:But when I was still doing that, I was noticing some of these things too.
Speaker:And our gaming group for tabletop, you know, 20 years ago
Speaker:you didn't see this, but now everybody's pulling out
Speaker:magnifying glasses and, lights and various other things.
Speaker:So I can see that being somewhat important.
Speaker:It is. And and it's it's easy to read.
Speaker:I mean, the text is not huge, but it's nice pleasing fonts and things like that.
Speaker:One other thing that I really liked,
Speaker:because if I'm dumping 25 or 30 bucks, I want to know what I'm getting.
Speaker:Sure.
Speaker:Of course, one thing that they did with their starter decks is right on the side.
Speaker:So it lists the character that it's designed around right on the side.
Speaker:It has criteria.
Speaker:I've got one here in front of me.
Speaker:Complexity, aggro, combo, survivability
Speaker:and utility are the five categories
Speaker:and it lists right on it how strong it is in each category.
Speaker:Okay, cool.
Speaker:So if I want to, using
Speaker:another game as an example, we'll use Magic The Gathering again.
Speaker:If I buy a
Speaker:starter deck, I have no idea what's in that deck.
Speaker:I have no idea how it's going to play.
Speaker:I have no idea what its strengths and weaknesses are.
Speaker:So there's all this time where I have to go in and I have to read,
Speaker:and I have to study, and I have to play tested a bunch in order
Speaker:to come up with it.
Speaker:This tells you right out of the box if you want to be a tank,
Speaker:this is the one for you.
Speaker:You pick high survivability, right?
Speaker:If you want to have a lot of of support and a lot of equipment
Speaker:that's going to play a part, you pick something with high utility.
Speaker:Now all the way around.
Speaker:This sounds like a amazing game.
Speaker:I like the idea that they're making it a little more open to people.
Speaker:You know, once upon a time, gaming was something that everybody could do,
Speaker:and it seems like these days it's getting so expensive in some ways
Speaker:that it excludes stuff and where you can,
Speaker:you know, have a thing
Speaker:where you can actually print your own cards when you need to,
Speaker:that kind of stuff that that to me just lowers the barrier to entry.
Speaker:I mean, you know, try printing your own stuff in Warhammer.
Speaker:I made that suggestion once about 20 years ago.
Speaker:I still haven't
Speaker:been allowed back in the city where this gaming group was, much less.
Speaker:Yeah,
Speaker:well, and you tie it in,
Speaker:looking at some of these games and the,
Speaker:You look at the, the people that are getting into them
Speaker:and Pokemon is a is a great example.
Speaker:It is getting so expensive
Speaker:and so difficult to find packs because people are scalping them.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:This is one that's a new one that's coming out
Speaker:that they're intentionally keeping down in.
Speaker:The scalpers are going to stay down because of the proxy cards.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So right now it's 30 bucks to get into, and it's probably
Speaker:still going to be 30 bucks to get into
Speaker:five years from now.
Speaker:Hopefully it's still going strong then and has several seasons out.
Speaker:I know it's just it it is a shame sometimes when it gets to a point from
Speaker:actually being able to play the game to, you know, some of these other things.
Speaker:I know I got a big box of stuff at a garage sale a number of years ago
Speaker:and had some magic cards, and one of them happened to be one called a Black Lotus.
Speaker:And I didn't know anything about magic and was using the thing as a bookmark
Speaker:for several years until somebody thought that I had completely lost my mind.
Speaker:And then when they told me what it was worth, I thought I
Speaker:they might have been right.
Speaker:But the thing of it is, is that takes that system from not being something
Speaker:you're using for fun anymore to something that, you know,
Speaker:you look out on a shelf and or even scared to do that.
Speaker:So it does change the,
Speaker:I don't know, just change what it's about.
Speaker:Well, and that ties in for just about any game, not just a trading card game.
Speaker:I want a game that I can play.
Speaker:I want a game that I can have fun with my friends.
Speaker:I want a
Speaker:easy example.
Speaker:Dungeons and Dragons.
Speaker:I look back at the books I had when I was.
Speaker:10 or 12 advanced mentions in Dragons, right?
Speaker:I had bookmarks, pages, dog eared and, you know, notes
Speaker:written in margins and all sorts of stuff because all of us shared the same books.
Speaker:Go in with your friends, everybody chips in five bucks and you buy a buy
Speaker:a new book, and then everybody has their notations in it.
Speaker:And I look at the modern books that I have, and I couldn't imagine doing that
Speaker:50 bucks a pop.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:It's like, wait a minute.
Speaker:This is a different
Speaker:I want something that gets
Speaker:the happy lived in look rather than
Speaker:having fun with it.
Speaker:It's not, you know, the artwork has its place.
Speaker:I love artwork and not saying anything negative about it,
Speaker:but it's designed to go look out on the wall and enjoy it.
Speaker:But it's not something you use for this kind of an activity.
Speaker:And it seems like these crosses the bridges to that.
Speaker:Although I guess with modern stuff now instead of,
Speaker:you know, spending five bucks to buy a book,
Speaker:you buy your book and
Speaker:then you get an electronic application, then you buy all your books again,
Speaker:and then you pay a monthly fee to be able to use those books.
Speaker:I think I prefer the dog eared scenario a lot better.
Speaker:I do too, I.
Speaker:There's something about having
Speaker:there's something about having that hard copy in your hands,
Speaker:and the smell of the pages and the feel of the cards and all of that.
Speaker:That makes it a lot better, I will admit, for
Speaker:modern gaming and a lot of series,
Speaker:I have taken to using some digital assistants,
Speaker:but one of the reasons there is
Speaker:they have gotten so complex
Speaker:that you have to.
Speaker:Dungeons and Dragons
Speaker:segueing a little bit Advanced Dungeons and Dragons,
Speaker:you had like five abilities that you needed to worry about
Speaker:modern Dungeons and Dragons, you've got 30 abilities
Speaker:you need to worry about, and you need reference text on every one of those.
Speaker:Right, right.
Speaker:It used to be rolled a hit.
Speaker:Now it's rolled to do this, which does that, which ties
Speaker:in with this, which does this so that you can finally roll the hit.
Speaker:But on a
Speaker:positive, you can just ask your AI agent to hack your player's character.
Speaker:So, you know, maybe that makes up for it.
Speaker:All right, so World of Kylie, am I saying that right?
Speaker:Kalia? Kalia, where do you get it?
Speaker:They have a website world of Kalia.
Speaker:Com Kylie's
Speaker:KLIA you can log on there.
Speaker:You can order anything that they have available.
Speaker:You can go through check prices.
Speaker:It's also where you can find the proxy cards.
Speaker:You can find comic books.
Speaker:You can find short stories.
Speaker:They did give me a short story.
Speaker:I believe it was Tale of Two Daggers was the name of it.
Speaker:Well written.
Speaker:I enjoyed what I've read of it so far.
Speaker:I haven't finished it quite yet, but they're really fleshing this out
Speaker:into a whole world rather than just a couple of cards you put down on the table.
Speaker:No, it sounds amazing.
Speaker:Well, it's always a pleasure being here on the vault.
Speaker:We're gonna have to do this more often than, you know, once a year.
Speaker:Yeah, well, thank you very much
Speaker:for taking some time out of your day and spending some time listening to me.
Speaker:Now, Toron, thank you very much for coming on the show, Bill.
Speaker:Always a pleasure.
Speaker:All right.
Speaker:We'll talk to you next time on the vault.
Speaker:So the vault is back.
Speaker:Check it out at the vault dot show.
Speaker:James, thank you for joining us today.
Speaker:So we've got a little bit of time left here.
Speaker:And I'm going to give a quick update on something that we've been working on.
Speaker:And we've talked about a little bit in the past.
Speaker:We did a show earlier this year on retro game consoles.
Speaker:And so I've been working on this purely in the name of science,
Speaker:getting everything I have actually set up, and I've run into some problems.
Speaker:I believe these would be considered first world problems that on my amplifier,
Speaker:my receiver unit, it only has ten HDMI inputs and I'm out of HDMI input.
Speaker:So that's a problem.
Speaker:And so I'm getting these switches and stuff to be able to take
Speaker:all the composite inputs and put them in and all that kind of thing.
Speaker:But it's taking a map to figure out what goes where,
Speaker:but I'm going to get it to work.
Speaker:And I think one of the things I'd like to do is go through later this year.
Speaker:And we've had a lot of questions come in on the different things
Speaker:related to this and talk about things like ever drive
Speaker:and some of the ways that you can get your old games to work.
Speaker:You know,
Speaker:I know last week we talked about the fact that it seems like
Speaker:the PS5 will now play everything, so that might be your one stop.
Speaker:But if you want to do it legally, there are other ways to be able to do it
Speaker:and actually play on the actual hardware fairly inexpensively and make it work.
Speaker:But there are some gotchas to being able to get into that and online
Speaker:with this, another device that's come out that is going to be kind of cool.
Speaker:It's going to be released next year if they make the date is
Speaker:we know that Commodore is back, Atari is back, and they've been remaking
Speaker:rereleasing some of their old consoles, but not just kind of a cheap
Speaker:third party release, stuff
Speaker:that actually works properly and does what it's supposed to do.
Speaker:And while these are re, what would we call it, respawns, I guess
Speaker:in gamer terms of the original companies, they still do hold the
Speaker:the rights to be able to do it and are doing a nice job.
Speaker:New components for being able to do all the things.
Speaker:Well, the latest thing that's been announced that was a
Speaker:little bit of a surprise is a rerelease of the Atari 800 XL,
Speaker:and this was one of the Atari eight bit lines from the early 80s.
Speaker:They stopped making them in 93 when Atari finally went out of business.
Speaker:But it it looks like it is a unit that is going to be pretty faithful
Speaker:to the original. It's the same size.
Speaker:It has a mechanical keyboard in the sense that it's mechanical keys.
Speaker:I have no idea if it's membrane or not,
Speaker:or if they're actual switches, but if physical keyboard
Speaker:it has a live cartridge slot, so it'll run your games if you have them.
Speaker:It also has a USB input.
Speaker:l run anything from the Atari:Speaker:For anybody that knows what that is, and you know it's going to be a situation
Speaker:where it'll be kind of another thing out there that's going to be interesting
Speaker:to see how well this works.
Speaker:The one thing that I just from looking at the specs question is it's
Speaker:USB instead of the original SDI oh port that would have been on,
Speaker:but maybe it'll make an adapter for that, because right now, as it stands,
Speaker:it wouldn't work with a lot of the old peripherals,
Speaker:but I'm sure there's a way that the community will figure that out.
Speaker:So just another thing that's coming up. It's going to be out next year.
Speaker:We'll review it when we get our hands on it.
Speaker:Until next week,
Speaker:this is User Friendly 2.0 keeping you safe on the cutting edge. User Friendly 2.0.
Speaker:Copyright:Speaker:by User Friendly Productions, LLC.
Speaker:All rights reserved.
Speaker:The views and opinions
Speaker:expressed on this program are those of the individual participants,
Speaker:and do not necessarily reflect those of this station, platform
Speaker:or User Friendly Productions, LLC.
Speaker:Requests for content, interviews, disclosures, and other information
Speaker:may be viewed or submitted at UserFriendly.Show
Speaker:Thank you for listening.


